INVESTMENT · BUSINESS · IMMIGRATION+1 647 805 1500
Book a consultation

Living in Canada for 7 Years Still Facing Deportation: Why Didn't the H&C Application Help the Family Stay?

November 17, 2026 | Canada Immigration News – KeyApply

A student in Montreal faces the risk of having to leave Canada with her family before the end of December 2026, despite having lived here for seven years, currently attending a college, and having applied for permanent residency under the Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) category about two years ago.

The case was published by Global News on November 17, 2026, raising the question: Why can a family that has lived in Canada for many years, with a child in school and an H&C application pending, still be deported?

From Colombia to Canada: Seven Years Building a New Life

According to Global News, Luisa Juliana Chaves Munoz and her family came to Canada from Colombia in 2019 to seek asylum.

Juliana stated that her family left their home country due to violence and death threats against her mother.

However, the family's asylum application was subsequently denied. The article did not disclose the specific legal reasons for this decision.

During their time in Canada, Juliana continued her education and is currently enrolled in the CEGEP program at Dawson College in Montreal.

The family stated that they had spent approximately CAD 28,000 on tuition. Juliana expects to complete the program in August 2027.

However, on October 15, 2026, the family received notice that they must leave Canada before the end of December 2026.

This means Juliana risks having to stop her studies before completing the program.

H&C Application Submitted Two Years Ago, So Why Still Deported?

This is the most important legal point of the case.

According to Global News, Juliana's family submitted an application for permanent residency under the Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) category about two years ago.

However, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) confirms that submitting an H&C application does not invalidate a deportation order. The permanent residency application continues to be reviewed, but this process can take many years.

In other words, there are two different legal processes:

  • H&C Application Review: Immigration authorities assess whether the applicant has sufficient humanitarian and compassionate grounds to be considered for permanent residency.
  • Enforcement of a Deportation Order: The relevant authority carries out the requirement for a person who no longer has the legal right to stay to leave Canada.

These two processes can occur simultaneously.

Therefore, having submitted an H&C application, or even waiting for a result for many years, does not automatically mean the applicant is permitted to continue staying in Canada.

Why Are Teachers and Students Protesting?

Teachers and students at Dawson College believe that Juliana's family should at least be given the opportunity for her to complete her studies.

According to teacher Andrew Katz, if Juliana completes the CEGEP program, she will receive a recognized diploma. Conversely, having to leave Canada before graduating could mean that her years of study will not result in a full diploma.

Juliana also stated that she has almost no remaining connection to Colombia after leaving the country as a child.

On November 16, Dawson College students and faculty began a campaign to write letters to federal Members of Parliament, asking the government to review the family's case.

The office of Member of Parliament Alexandra Mendès confirmed that they are working with the family but did not disclose details due to privacy concerns.

As of the time Global News published the article on November 17, there has been no confirmation that the deportation order has been stayed or canceled.

What Is H&C, and What Factors May Be Considered?

Humanitarian and Compassionate (H&C) is a mechanism that allows certain people to request consideration for permanent residency in Canada based on humanitarian and compassionate factors.

Depending on the application, factors that may be considered include:

  1. The applicant's level of stability and integration in Canada.
  2. Family and community ties that have been established.
  3. The hardships that may be faced if forced to leave Canada.
  4. The best interests of children directly affected by the decision.
  5. Other relevant special humanitarian circumstances.

However, H&C is not an automatic permanent residency program for those who have lived in Canada for many years.

Attending school, working, paying taxes, or living in Canada for many years may be factors that are assessed, but these factors alone do not guarantee that an application will be approved.

In addition, the best interests of children is an important factor when children are affected, but it does not automatically determine the outcome of the application.

What Should Those Waiting for an H&C Decision Pay Particular Attention To?

Juliana's family's case highlights a risk that many people may not fully understand: An ongoing permanent residency application does not necessarily create a legal right to stay or prevent the enforcement of a deportation order.

Those waiting for an H&C decision need to clearly distinguish between three issues:

  • Their current immigration status in Canada.
  • The status of their permanent residency application.
  • Whether there is an active deportation order.

If they have received notice from the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA), the applicant should immediately have an immigration lawyer or licensed representative assess the deadlines, decisions, and legal remedies that may be available.

In some cases, it may be necessary to consider requesting a stay of the deportation order or other legal procedures. However, the likelihood of success depends on the specific circumstances and there is no guarantee that the request will be approved.

Lessons from the Case: Living in Canada for a Long Time Does Not Automatically Grant Permanent Residency

Juliana's story raises a compelling humanitarian issue: A young person who has spent most of their youth studying and building a life in Canada may have to leave before completing their studies.

However, legally, the length of time lived in Canada and the level of integration do not automatically replace the requirements of immigration law.

The case also highlights the difference between being considered for permanent residency under the H&C category and having the right to continue staying in Canada while waiting for a decision.

For families whose asylum applications have been denied or who are considering applying for H&C, developing a legal strategy early on is very important, especially when there is a risk of a deportation order being enforced.

KeyApply Reminders

Every H&C application has its own circumstances and legal grounds. Applicants should not assume that submitting an H&C application will automatically allow them to stay in Canada while waiting for a decision.

KeyApply provides orientation services and connects clients with licensed immigration lawyers or RCICs to assess and carry out appropriate legal representation procedures.

Website: https://keyapply.com

WhatsApp/Zalo: +1 647 993 9654


FREE ONLINE SEMINAR WITH LAWYER ROBIN SELIGMAN

KeyApply invites the Vietnamese community to attend an online seminar on Canadian immigration legal issues, including asylum applications, H&C, immigration status, the risk of denial, CBSA-related issues, and avoiding immigration fraud.

Speaker: Lawyer Robin Seligman - Seligman Law

Time: Sunday, November 29, 2026, 9:00–10:30 a.m. Toronto time (9:00–10:30 p.m. Vietnam time)

Format: Zoom, free attendance

REGISTER FOR THE FREE SEMINAR

View seminar information

The seminar provides general legal information and does not replace individual legal advice for each application.


References

Global News – “After 7 years in Canada, young student faces deportation”, published November 17, 2026.

https://globalnews.ca/news/12153885/canada-student-deportation-montreal-que-dawson/

Các bài viết liên quan

New Brunswick Eases AIP for the Restaurant Industry: Opportunities for Cooks, Chefs, and Bakers
New Brunswick's Atlantic Immigration Program (AIP) policy has notable changes for the accommodati...
Đọc thêm
Immigrating to Canada from Vietnam: PR programs for workers without a prior Work Permit (2026)
Updated October 17, 2026. In addition to Express Entry, RCIP, and FCIP, workers currently in Viet...
Đọc thêm
LATEST NEWS 16/10/2026: Canada may soon increase immigration targets - Minister Lena Diab signals new direction
Updated October 16, 2026. According to a CTV News report on October 16, 2026, Canadian Minister o...
Đọc thêm

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published