INVESTMENT · BUSINESS · IMMIGRATION+1 647 805 1500
Book a consultation

Fairness in the application process

This section contains the policies, procedures, and guidance used by IRCC staff. Decision-makers are required to follow the rules of procedural fairness throughout the decision-making process.

Fairness requires that the applicant be:

  • given a fair and impartial assessment of their application
  • informed of the decision-maker’s concerns, and the applicant be given an opportunity to provide a response to these concerns

The requirement for procedural fairness applies to all types of immigration and citizenship applications and in all aspects of decision-making.

Discuss your case with KeyApply

Provide your needs, application status, and goals regarding the service you are interested in so that KeyApply can discuss the appropriate support direction.

Book a consultation appointment

Email: info@keyapply.com. You can call, email, or message via the website KeyApply.com.

Key elements of procedural fairness

  • Processing without undue delay
  • The right to a fair and impartial decision-maker
  • The right of the applicant to be heard
  • The person who hears the case must decide the case
  • Legitimate expectations
  • Decisions must be based on the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) and Regulations (IRPR)
  • The right to reasons

Processing without undue delay

Applications will not be delayed unnecessarily. Unjustified delay is contrary to procedural fairness.

The right to a fair and impartial decision-maker

Applicants have the right to a fair and impartial decision-maker.

Examples of situations of bias, or apprehended bias, may include:

  • prejudging an issue before it is heard
  • biased attitudes
  • inferences from previous cases
  • a relationship between the decision-maker and one of the parties (e.g., financial interest), etc.

The right of the applicant to be heard

When an individual is affected by a decision, they have the right to know the reasons and must be given a fair opportunity to respond.

The "right to be heard" requires that the applicant be informed of significant facts likely to affect the outcome of the application. For example, if a decision-maker relies on extrinsic evidence (i.e., evidence obtained from sources other than the applicant), they must inform the applicant of this and provide them with an opportunity to respond to that evidence.

To ensure the applicant has a meaningful opportunity to participate, decision-makers must provide full notification of any process or interview that may result in a decision on their application, and must provide the applicant with a reasonable opportunity to present evidence or make arguments in support of their application. Decision-makers should inform the applicant what documents may be required to address their concerns. Full information should be included in the interview invitation letter to allow the applicant to prepare. If any other concerns arise from an interview, decision-makers should provide the applicant with an opportunity to address those concerns at the interview or after the interview, via a procedural fairness letter.

The right to be heard does not necessarily include the right to an interview, although in some cases, an interview may be the most appropriate way to proceed. If the applicant is interviewed, they should be permitted to bring an interpreter, or in certain circumstances, should be provided with an interpreter.

The right to be heard requires that the applicant have a meaningful opportunity to participate in the process. This requirement also applies to information received from third parties, including IRCC partners. While this does not mean the decision-maker must provide the factual documents referenced in the decision-making process (El Maghraoui, 2013 FC 883), there is a requirement that the substance of the decision-maker’s concerns be communicated to the applicant (Krishnamoorthy, 2011 FC 1342) and the applicant be advised of the specific provisions of the Act that are in question. It is essential that the decision-maker’s concerns be clearly communicated to the applicant, who must then be given a reasonable opportunity to respond.

The person who hears the case must decide the case

The person who hears the case is the one who makes the final decision.

“Hearing” in this context does not mean an interview. It means the person with decision-making authority must evaluate the information provided and make a decision. The Act, Regulations, and various delegated instruments specifically prescribe who has the authority to make a decision.

When decision-makers exercise their decision-making authority, they will evaluate information in the context of the applicable law. If the decision-maker is the only one who views the information or deals with the applicants, then it is clear that they have “heard” and decided. However, during the processing stage, different individuals may work on a specific file. Therefore, it is important that all documents provided by the applicant be placed on the record (electronic file or paper file) for the decision-maker’s review. The decision record must also show that the decision-maker considered all relevant factors, including all submissions from the applicant, and that they made their own decision based on the file.

If a decision is based on subjective assessments (e.g., credibility), the record must clearly state that the decision-maker performed the assessment. A decision-maker should not rely on the subjective assessment of another; they must make the decision themselves based on complete information and must provide factual and objective reasons for their decision.

In some cases, responsibility for the file may be transferred to another decision-maker. The new decision-maker must ensure that all information on the file has been evaluated and it must be clear in the notes that this has been done. When a file is transferred to another decision-maker, it may be necessary to send a new procedural fairness letter or even re-interview the applicant, especially if subjective assessments made by the previous decision-maker are relevant to the final decision on the file.

Ultimately, the requirement that the person who hears must decide does not preclude a decision-maker from seeking advice before making a final decision; however, the decision record must indicate that, after evaluating all relevant factors, the decision-maker reached their own conclusion. The decision-maker may use advice received from a manager, from senior leadership, or from procedural manuals that guide the practical application of the Act and Regulations to the file. If a decision-maker makes a decision because of the direction of a manager, senior leadership, or procedural guidelines, it remains their individual decision.

Legitimate expectations

When a person has been assured that a specific procedure will be followed, that individual has a right to that procedure. For example, if an applicant has been given 30 days to provide certain documents, a negative decision should not be made before the end of that 30-day period even if some documents have already been received.

Decisions must be based on the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) and Regulations (IRPR)

The provision of the Act or Regulations must be cited in the refusal record. All communication with the applicant, including refusal letters, must reference the appropriate legislative provision(s).

The right to reasons

Applicants have the right to understand the basis for the decision made on their application. The reasons, which must be provided in writing, should be clear, accurate, and easy to understand. When an applicant has the right to appeal to the IAD or apply for judicial review at the Federal Court, the applicant must have sufficient information to prepare their submissions. The reasons provided to the applicant must reflect an assessment of the facts and evidence relied upon, the provision(s) of the Act and/or Regulations upon which the decision is based, and the rationale for the decision-maker’s conclusion.

BOOK AN APPOINTMENT WITH US NOW IF YOU HAVE AN APPEAL ISSUE